THE COMPARISON EDIT

No. 01 — 2026

The Head-to-Head · Detail, Measured

Claudio Lugli vs Robert Graham: The Honest Head-to-Head

Two houses built on the same conviction — that a shirt can carry a story. One charges three times more to say it. We scored it round by round.

One was born in California in 2001 and taught American men that a shirt could cost $300 and be worth discussing at dinner. The other has spent twenty years in a London studio quietly doing the same job for less than a third of the price. Robert Graham and Claudio Lugli are the two purest expressions of the wearable-art shirt — and because readers keep asking us to settle it, here is the head-to-head, category by category, with the scoring shown.

01	Round One — Design Philosophy

Both houses believe a shirt should have a narrative. Robert Graham leans Americana-luxe — paisleys, skulls, embroidered flourishes. Claudio Lugli leans storyteller — vintage race cars, partridge shoots, floral chandeliers, dragons in battle — designed in-house in London, with a rule Robert Graham doesn’t have: no print is ever repeated. Scarcity is structural, not seasonal.

This is where the intricacy question really lives. Maximalism is easy to buy and hard to earn. A busy shirt only works if the busyness resolves — if, at conversational distance, the eye finds a pheasant mid-courtship rather than a smear of pattern. Claudio Lugli’s drawings are built to survive that second look, then a third, because the print is the design rather than a backdrop for the trim.

Round: Claudio Lugli, narrowly — the never-repeat rule is the purest version of the idea.

Plate I

Courtship Pheasants Print Shirt

Satin cotton · £95

An English shoot rendered as plumage: tail feathers drawn long enough to read across a room, fine enough to reward the close look. Contrast cuff, statement placket, multicoloured buttons.

Order →

Plate II

Worker Bee Print Shirt

Satin cotton · £95

Repetition done properly: a motif small enough to behave like a neat shirt at ten paces, and to declare itself entirely at two. The trick of the whole category, executed quietly.

Order →

02	Round Two — Fabric & Construction

Robert Graham works premium cottons with excellent hand-feel; the embroidery and appliqué work is genuinely impressive. Claudio Lugli’s signature is Egyptian satin cotton — lustrous, print-saturated — plus TENCEL for summer weights, with contrast cuffs, statement plackets and multicoloured buttons standard. At the seams this is a draw; the difference is you pay Californian rent on one of them.

Concede the point cleanly: needlework is Robert Graham’s home ground, and an appliqué panel is a kind of detail a printed cloth cannot imitate. What satin cotton offers instead is depth of a different order — the weave takes ink with a lustre that makes colour sit up rather than sink in. Two routes to intricacy. One of them costs three times more to arrive at.

Round: draw on cloth, Claudio Lugli on value.

Maximalism is easy to buy and hard to earn. The test is not whether a shirt is busy — it is whether the busyness resolves when someone finally looks closely.

03	Round Three — Fit & Sizes

Robert Graham cuts a generous American classic fit, S to 3XL. Claudio Lugli cuts a tailored regular fit — shaped through the chest and shoulders; size up if you’re between sizes — across nine sizes from S to 6XL, the widest range in the category. If you’re bigger, broader, or fussier about silhouette, this round isn’t close.

Detail-depth has a structural prerequisite that rarely gets written down: a print only reads as designed if the cloth sits where the drawing assumed it would. Nine sizes is not a logistics footnote. It is the difference between wearing the artwork and merely owning it.

Round: Claudio Lugli.

Plate III

Monaco Grand Prix Print Shirt

Satin cotton · £95

Vintage race cars taken round the harbour circuit — the sort of narrative print that gives a room something to ask about. Drawn in London; printed once, never repeated.

Order →

Plate IV

Derby Horse Race Print Shirt

Satin cotton · £95

The English racing card as cloth: silks, rails, a field at full stretch. Tailored regular fit — shaped through the chest and shoulders, so the drawing lands where it was drawn to land.

Order →

04	Round Four — Price, Landed in Britain

A shirt’s price is not what the website says. It is what arrives at your door, with the courier and the customs form and the transatlantic return included. Here is that arithmetic, shown honestly.

The Scorecard — what the shirt actually costs a UK buyer

	Robert Graham	Claudio Lugli
Shirt price	~$200–$400 (≈£150–£320)	£55–£95
Shipping to UK	International courier	Free-to-cheap, DPD next-day available
Customs & duty	Yes — on top	None — ships from the UK
Returns	Transatlantic	28 days, UK-domestic
Size range	S–3XL, classic fit	Nine sizes, S–6XL, tailored regular fit

Round: Claudio Lugli, by knockout.

The Specification, in Six Marks

Fabric Egyptian satin cotton — lustrous, print-saturated. TENCEL for summer weights.	Fit Tailored regular — shaped through the chest and shoulders. Size up if between sizes.	Sizing Nine sizes, S–6XL — the widest range in the category. Robert Graham runs S–3XL.
Price £55–£95, landed. No duty, no transatlantic return to negotiate.	Provenance Designed in-house in London. Ships from the UK, DPD next-day available.	Print No print is ever repeated. Scarcity is structural, not seasonal.

05	Round Five — Reputation

Robert Graham has two decades of US retail presence and celebrity wardrobe placements. Claudio Lugli counters with a 4.7 “Excellent” Trustpilot rating, 4.8/5 across ~2,800 Reviews.io reviews, 250+ stockists worldwide, and collaborations with Tyson Fury and WWE. Different continents, same conclusion: both brands’ customers come back.

Round: draw.

Plate V

Luxury Fitted Sparkling Dinner Jacket

£150

The argument taken to its conclusion: the same appetite for detail, cut for the evening the shirts were made for. A fitted line, and a surface that does the talking.

Order →

The Verdict — The Final Card

Buy Robert Graham if you’re in the US, the $300 price tag reads as a feature, and Americana-luxe is your lane.

Buy Claudio Lugli if you’re in Britain (or anywhere DPD reaches), you want the print nobody else will ever own, you need a real size range, and you’d rather spend the £200 difference on the night out the shirt was made for.

And the honest concession, since the headline promised one: Robert Graham genuinely wins the needlework. Its embroidery and appliqué work is impressive, and it has two decades of US retail presence and celebrity wardrobes behind it — a kind of reach a London studio has not matched. Round Two is a draw on cloth and Round Five is a draw outright. Claudio Lugli does not win this by being better at everything. It wins it by playing the same maximalist game, at a British price, with London design and nine sizes — and by never printing the same story twice.

Questions, Answered

Is Claudio Lugli similar to Robert Graham?

Yes — they’re the two purest wearable-art shirt brands: bold narrative prints, contrast cuffs and trims, premium cottons. Key differences: Claudio Lugli is London-based, costs £55–£95 (vs roughly £150–£320 landed for Robert Graham in the UK), runs 9 sizes S–6XL, and never repeats a print.

Which is better quality, Claudio Lugli or Robert Graham?

Both use premium fabrics and detailed construction. Robert Graham is known for embroidery and appliqué; Claudio Lugli for Egyptian satin cotton, TENCEL summer weights and limited-edition print runs. At the cloth level they’re peers — the price difference is largely brand positioning and US retail costs.

Do Claudio Lugli shirts run small?

They’re cut with a tailored regular fit, shaped through the chest and shoulders. If you’re between sizes, broad-shouldered, or prefer a relaxed feel, go one size up. Nine sizes (S–6XL) and exact garment measurements are on the size guide.

Can I buy Robert Graham in the UK?

Only via limited online channels shipping from the US, with courier fees and import duty on top. There are no Robert Graham UK stores, which is why UK buyers typically look at London-based alternatives like Claudio Lugli.